Crist, Perry: A Study in Contrasts

 

While Governor Rick Perry celebrated his commanding victory over U.S. Senator Kay Bailey Hutchison in Tuesday's Republican gubernatorial primary in Texas, Florida Governor Charlie Crist delivered his final State of the State speech to lawmakers in Tallahassee. The two events seemed to crystallize the opposite ends of the GOP, and the two Republican governors' divergent campaign fortunes. 

  In Texas, voters' "yes" to Perry was an emphatic "no" to Washington, as The New York Times characterized the race on its front page. What once had seemed like a serious threat to Perry from the more moderate Hutchison fizzled away as the twice-elected governor railed against the federal government on his way to an easy win. Perry easily was able to characterize Hutchison as part of the Washington system that "tea party" voters and many others recently have repudiated.

In Perry's victory, The Times sees the extension of a national conservative trend that started in Massachusetts in January: "The Republican primary in Texas reflects the grass-roots rebellion among conservatives against moderate Republicans and Democrats that has shaken up politics across the country," the paper said, "beginning with the defeat of the Democratic candidate for Senate in Massachusetts by Scott Brown, a Republican."

Enter Charlie Crist. The moderate governor of Florida, who has praised the federal stimulus while other Republican governors have attacked it, is locked in a difficult U.S. Senate campaign against the more conservative Marco Rubio, the former speaker of the Florida House. Polls have shown Crist trailing Rubio by double digits, and there even is speculation that Crist may run as an independent as a result of his obvious difficulties in the primary.

"The man addressing the Legislature on Tuesday night is no longer a national model for Republican success, but rather a national model for endangered Republicans," the St. Petersburg Times wrote in an analysis . "He is a Republican Senate candidate fighting for his political life and he sounded less like Mr. Nice Guy than a combative and unapologetic candidate determined to cast frontrunner Marco Rubio as small and petty."

Crist used his speech to push once again for a pragmatic, not ideological, approach to governing, even as he landed sharp attacks on Rubio, The Times reported. "Our practical solutions will serve only to inflame extremists," Crist told lawmakers on Tuesday. "Take heart, knowing that it is we problem-solvers — and not they — who will move our Florida forward."

 

 
X

Related Stories

    • Stateline Story
    November 30, 2010
    image description

    TRANSITION WATCH: Democrats in Wisconsin look to approve lame-duck labor deals, Arizona contemplates its immigration encore, and other news of the historic shift in power in the states.
    more

    • Stateline Story
    November 12, 2010
    image description

    TRANSITION WATCH: Democrats in Massachusetts look to get along by turning their attention away from gambling, Florida's new governor faces a choice on high-speed rail and other news of the historic shift in power in the states.
    more

    • Stateline Story
    September 2, 2008
    image description

    Sept. 2, 2008, 1:30 p.m. EDTST. PAUL, Minn. - Hurricane Gustav forced some of the biggest stars in the Republican Party to stay at home to help their consitutents battle the storm that many feared would rival Hurricane Katrina of just three years ago.   But four of the five affected southern Republican governors addressed the opening session of the 2008 Republican National Convention Monday (Sept. 1) via taped messages. "I'm sure you can understand why Gov. Jindal couldn't participate," first lady Laura Bush said as she introduced the taped messages, referring to Republican Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal as his state was being pounded by Gustav's strong winds and rain.   Jindal had been rumored to be, among others, on Republican John McCain's shortlist of possible vice presidential picks before the senator chose Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin.   President Bush had been scheduled to address the delegates Monday but instead went to Texas to monitor the storm. The administration had been widely criticized for its handling of Hurricane Katrina. Some Republicans, notably Texas Gov. Rick Perry, stressed that the GOP was ready. "You're seeing Republican governors ... doing a fabulous job of taking care of the citizens. That's what we do," he said via videotape.Texas Gov. Rick Perry on Hurricane Gustav   The first lady also noted the governors of the affected states "happen to be Republicans," which drew a thunderous applause from the delegates at the Xcel Energy Center in St. Paul.   Florida Charlie Crist, another Republican governor who also was seen as a possible VP candidate, took a less partisan approach in his remarks, remembering his experience during last month's Tropical Storm Fay: "As I traveled our state in the days following Fay's landfall, I was reminded again of the resilience and strength of our people. The kindness they extend to one another. Neighbor helping neighbor. Asking not what party you are, but instead how you can help."   Alabama Gov. Bob Riley and Mississippi Gov. Haley Barbour also gave videotaped messages. Governor Jindal said Monday that seven states are helping Louisiana to shelter more than 29,000 citizens at 107 shelters. Texas has offered to shelter several thousand patients, Oklahoma has agreed to accept 4,000 general evacuees, and 150 medical patients from southwest Louisiana hospitals are expected to arrive at the Oklahoma Air National Guard Base at Will Rogers Airport in Oklahoma City today.   The state Republican chairmen from Alabama, Florida, Louisiana, Mississippi and Texas formed a working group "to regularly brief their delegates and convention planners, provide access to timely information and assistance, and give input on appropriate steps that can be taken from Minnesota."   The McCain 2008 campaign also agreed to charter a DC-9 to transport delegates who wished to return to home to their states.AFTER THE JUMP: More video footage of the governors on Hurricane Gustav.   - Pamela M. Prah Comments
    more

    • Stateline Story
    November 29, 2010
    image description

    TRANSITION WATCH: Almost half the members of the New York governor-elect's transition team serve groups that lobby the state, skepticism on corrections privatization in Florida and other news of the historic shift in power in the states.  
    more

    • Stateline Story
    November 22, 2010
    image description

    TRANSITION WATCH: Iowa's outgoing governor locks in his successor with higher employee salaries, California's Jerry Brown wants to flatten the structure of the governor's office, and other news of the historic shift in power in the states.
    more

PCS.PRODUCTION.1.20140221.1210 (PEWSUWVMWAPP01)