Hope fading for GOP gains in La. Legislature


The 2007 election season couldn't have started out much more promising for Republicans in Louisiana , a state that has remained a Democratic stronghold in an era of GOP dominance in the rest of the Deep South .

Republican U.S. Rep. Bobby Jindal was heavily favored to win the governorship held by outgoing Democrat Kathleen Blanco. And the term-limits law pushed through by U.S. Sen. David Vitter (R-La.) when he was a state legislator in 1995 was finally kicking in, affecting about half the seats in the House and Senate. 

If ever there was a year when Republicans had a chance to claim a majority in either chamber - a first since Reconstruction - this was it. To help the cause, Vitter formed a political action committee, the Louisiana Committee for a Republican Majority, to pour money into targeted races.

Now, Jindal is heading to the governor's mansion, having been spared a runoff by winning 54 percent of the vote in Louisiana 's all-party primary Oct. 20. But the GOP's plan to extend that dominance to the Legislature appears to be falling short of its initial expectations.

As the Nov. 17 runoff approaches, Democrats are assured of retaining at least 22 seats for a majority in the 39-member Senate, while four seats are still up for grabs by either party. (There are also five all-Democratic runoffs and one all-Republican contest on the ballot.)

Click here to see the Stateline.org interactive guide to the 2007 elections (Flash)

The 105-member House remains in play, but most analysts predict the Democrats will retain a slim majority. Heading into Saturday's runoff, Democrats are assured of holding 45 seats and Republicans 42.

Analysts credit the Democrats' success in recruiting conservative candidates for districts that were carried by President Bush in 2004 and Louisiana's longstanding proclivity for disregarding party labels in local and state elections.

In the House, the partisan makeup will be decided in 16 races that pit a Democrat against a Republican, and one in which a Democrat faces an independent who usually votes with Republicans. The GOP needs to win 11 of those races to earn a majority. Another 22 runoffs are intra-party contests that will have no effect on the partisan makeup.

Still, the prospect of a Democratic Legislature doesn't necessarily spell trouble for Louisiana 's new Republican governor because of a unique state tradition that gives governors great sway in the selection of House speaker and Senate president.

The Legislature is an independent branch of government, and Jindal said he is prepared to respect the right of the House and Senate to pick its own leadership. But the governor-elect also reserved the right to get involved if the selection process bogs down, and history suggests the matter won't be solved without some input from the new administration.

"I suspect he may be rethinking" his vow not to get involved in the leadership races, said Jim Brandt, president of the nonpartisan Public Affairs Research Council of Louisiana.

Or, as political analyst John Maginnis put it in The Times-Picayune : "Until he (Jindal) gets involved, deadlocks in both houses are assured, given the multiple candidates and the desire of many members to ingratiate themselves to the new governor. With or without meddling from Jindal, there is a good chance the next House speaker will be a Republican even if Democrats retain a slim House majority. Several conservative Democrats likely could be persuaded to cross party lines to vote for a GOP speaker, especially if Jindal signals a preference. The speaker, in turn, is widely expected to appoint members of both parties to committee chairmanships and other leadership posts.

"It's not necessarily a Republican majority, but it's a conservative majority," said Pearson Cross, a professor of political science at the University of Louisiana-Lafayette. "I think Bobby Jindal will find them willing and able to play ball, and I think they will be amenable to his direction."

If Jindal's agenda should run aground, chances are it will happen in the Senate. While term limits will usher more than three dozen new members into the House, some of the veterans being forced from the lower chamber by term limits are simply walking across the hall to the Senate.

The House members who have moved up to the Senate include several longtime Democratic stalwarts, such as 36-year-veteran John Alario, who represents a blue-collar New Orleans suburb and has served as a floor leader under several Democratic governors, including Edwin Edwards. With a reputation as a consummate dealmaker, Alario is expected to seek a leadership post in the Senate, though he is not among the handful of lawmakers who are vying for the presidency.

The state GOP did itself no favors when it decided to pour money and resources into trying to defeat Alario's Senate bid in a race he still ended up winning easily with 62 percent of the primary vote on Oct. 20.

"The Senate is just an incredible roadblock, especially after they (Republicans) infuriated Alario to the point that they did," said Elliott Stonecipher, a Shreveport , La. , demographer and political analyst.

The first big test for Jindal, a 36-year-old policy wunderkind, will be a special session on ethics reform that the governor-elect has promised to call shortly after his Jan. 14 inauguration. Convinced that Louisiana 's well-earned reputation for corruption is keeping the state from attracting investment and newcomers the way other Southern states have in recent years, Jindal wants stronger financial-disclosure requirements for legislators and lobbyists and a ban on elected officials receiving state contracts.


Lawmakers managed to kill a much softer disclosure bill during the 2007 session, but expectations are that Jindal will be successful because he campaigned heavily on ethics reform and new governors traditionally enjoy a honeymoon period when their agendas are given great deference.


A study by the nonpartisan Center for Public Integrity examining the quality of states' 2004 financial-disclosure laws ranked Louisiana 44 th out of 47 states that require disclosure filings.


After the special session comes the nuts and bolts of daily governing and crafting a budget. But here again, Jindal enters from a position of strength, having inherited a $1 billion budget surplus and a state economy that is booming thanks to sky-high energy prices and a flood of post-Katrina rebuilding dollars.


"The good news, from his standpoint, is he starts out from a much stronger fiscal posture than other governors traditionally have," said Brandt, who serves as an unpaid adviser on fiscal matters to the Jindal transition team.


But that aside, a more fundamental question is whether Louisiana 's unique political culture of bipartisanship can remain intact. For generations, debates at the Capitol have been far more likely to break down along regional or racial lines than the partisan tit-for-tat that dominates many statehouses. That began to change during Blanco's administration, as the GOP inched closer to parity and controversial votes frequently broke down along party lines.


Jindal insists that he would like to see a return to the age of bipartisanship, calling it one of the few things that Louisiana has gotten right over the years. But many fear that the age of Washington, D.C.-style partisanship, symbolized by Vitter's PAC and similar fund-raising efforts on the part of Democrats, is here to stay.


"I think bipartisanship in Louisiana is really, if not at an end, certainly close to an end," said Cross, the political science professor. "We're heading towards increased partisan animosity and strife in this state, Mr. Jindal's statements notwithstanding."


Jan Moller is a state capital reporter for The Times-Picayune ( New Orleans ), where his beats include the state budget and health-care policy.

Comment on this story in the space below by registering with Stateline.org , or e-mail your feedback to our Letters to the editor section at letters@stateline.org .

See related stories:

Dems win Ky. gov seat, Va. Senate

2007 election: Lessons learned

Virginia Democrats aim for Senate win

GOP wins Louisiana governorship

N.J. election sees record number of women

Cancer research, vouchers on '07 ballots

Oregonians reconsider land-use measure

Fletcher struggles to overcome hiring probe

Who's in trouble in 14 gov races in '07, '08?

GOP eyes possible gains in '07 races

Virginia Democrats aim for Senate win


Original Stateline Story

Related Stories

    • Stateline Story
    February 3, 2011
    image description

    TODAY'S TAKE: The only Democratic attorney general to formally oppose the Obama administration's health care law in court, Louisiana's James "Buddy" Caldwell, has switched parties. He becomes the latest in a string of Louisiana Democrats to switch to the GOP. more

    • Stateline Story
    March 1, 2010
    image description

    Naming a new lieutenant governor in California has been no easy task. At one point last month, Republican Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger and the Democratic leaders of the Assembly fought over whether the Assembly had actually approved Schwarzenegger's pick for the post. In California, as in several other states, it's hard to keep in mind that the lieutenant governor's office is primarily designed to be a sort of insurance policy in case something happens to the governor. Instead, in several states like California, the position recently has been a political liability. The intrigue is even more baffling because many of the most hotly contested fights are in states where the lieutenant governor's powers are relatively weak.

    • Stateline Story
    September 2, 2008
    image description

    Sept. 2, 2008, 1:30 p.m. EDTST. PAUL, Minn. - Hurricane Gustav forced some of the biggest stars in the Republican Party to stay at home to help their consitutents battle the storm that many feared would rival Hurricane Katrina of just three years ago.   But four of the five affected southern Republican governors addressed the opening session of the 2008 Republican National Convention Monday (Sept. 1) via taped messages. "I'm sure you can understand why Gov. Jindal couldn't participate," first lady Laura Bush said as she introduced the taped messages, referring to Republican Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal as his state was being pounded by Gustav's strong winds and rain.   Jindal had been rumored to be, among others, on Republican John McCain's shortlist of possible vice presidential picks before the senator chose Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin.   President Bush had been scheduled to address the delegates Monday but instead went to Texas to monitor the storm. The administration had been widely criticized for its handling of Hurricane Katrina. Some Republicans, notably Texas Gov. Rick Perry, stressed that the GOP was ready. "You're seeing Republican governors ... doing a fabulous job of taking care of the citizens. That's what we do," he said via videotape.Texas Gov. Rick Perry on Hurricane Gustav   The first lady also noted the governors of the affected states "happen to be Republicans," which drew a thunderous applause from the delegates at the Xcel Energy Center in St. Paul.   Florida Charlie Crist, another Republican governor who also was seen as a possible VP candidate, took a less partisan approach in his remarks, remembering his experience during last month's Tropical Storm Fay: "As I traveled our state in the days following Fay's landfall, I was reminded again of the resilience and strength of our people. The kindness they extend to one another. Neighbor helping neighbor. Asking not what party you are, but instead how you can help."   Alabama Gov. Bob Riley and Mississippi Gov. Haley Barbour also gave videotaped messages. Governor Jindal said Monday that seven states are helping Louisiana to shelter more than 29,000 citizens at 107 shelters. Texas has offered to shelter several thousand patients, Oklahoma has agreed to accept 4,000 general evacuees, and 150 medical patients from southwest Louisiana hospitals are expected to arrive at the Oklahoma Air National Guard Base at Will Rogers Airport in Oklahoma City today.   The state Republican chairmen from Alabama, Florida, Louisiana, Mississippi and Texas formed a working group "to regularly brief their delegates and convention planners, provide access to timely information and assistance, and give input on appropriate steps that can be taken from Minnesota."   The McCain 2008 campaign also agreed to charter a DC-9 to transport delegates who wished to return to home to their states.AFTER THE JUMP: More video footage of the governors on Hurricane Gustav.   - Pamela M. Prah Comments

    • Stateline Story
    October 22, 2007
    image description

    Louisiana voters elected the country's first governor of Indian descent Saturday (Oct. 20) and gave the Republican Party control of yet another state executive suite in the South. Bobby Jindal also will become the youngest sitting governor at 36.

    • Stateline Story
    October 19, 2007
    image description

    Only in Louisiana, known for its peculiar election laws and devotion to college football, could a Louisiana State University football game once again play a role in deciding the victor in a governor's race.